(Artwork Via Pexels)
The headlines about AI can make it feel as though we are choosing between a technological miracle and the end of the world. As a nonprofit leader, you already have plenty to worry about: funding, staff and delivering on your mission.
Now you are being asked to make sense of a technology that promises enormous benefits while creating risks that even its developers struggle to predict. It can feel debilitating. But you don’t need to be a techie, a hacker or a cybersecurity expert to take action. You need to ask the right questions, set clear priorities and help your organization prepare. That is the work of leadership.
Few nonprofit leaders are technical leaders. Instead, many are focused on carrying out the organization’s purpose-driven mission. But every nonprofit leader owns their organization’s risk and, in turn, is instrumental in protecting the organization’s mission, reputation and service to members, donors and other stakeholders. The digital space is where all these elements (and more) live today.
Here are five recommendations for successfully leading on cybersecurity in the AI-forward world:
1) Know What Your Organization Is Up Against
Okta’s Nonprofits at Work 2026 report revealed that, in terms of identity controls, “nonprofits are the most-targeted industry, with the ratio of detected threats to authentications reaching 78%.”
Attackers know that many nonprofits grapple with constrained budgets and limited teams while holding an incredibly high bar of public trust. Not to mention that cybercriminals have their nefarious eyes on the treasure trove of data at hand: donor records, member data, information about beneficiaries and the underlying financial systems associated with donation operations.
Now, AI is changing the threat landscape, amplifying the speed, scale and believability of threats. Phishing, for instance, has always been the bane of every organization’s existence, but now nonprofits must contend with AI-generated phishing. Speed plus scale is a dangerous combination enabled by AI.
Then there’s social engineering. Emails may look completely legitimate as if they’re coming from you as the organizational leader, a board member or a colleague, but in reality are being faked by bots. Attackers are also using AI to clone voices and imitate leaders via AI-generated videos that can fool even the most vigilant among us.
These are just a couple of examples, so leaders must make sure they educate themselves and their teams to recognize these risks and, just as important, understand how to communicate them to various stakeholders. Ransomware, according to a CrowdStrike report, for instance, remains a serious threat for small businesses in particular.
2) Communicate Risk In The Language Of Resilience
When discussing cybersecurity with your board and staff, start with what is at stake for your mission. Could a cyber incident interrupt services, expose donor information or prevent you from paying employees? Framing the conversation around these consequences helps everyone understand why cybersecurity matters and what the organization needs to be prepared for.
Consider the word resilience itself. Broadly put, resilience is the ability to cope with stress and continue through it, ultimately to recover and then to thrive. Think about it: cyber incidents are not just technical disruptions; they can threaten organizational continuity, mission delivery, reputation and stakeholder confidence.
Communicating risk in that language helps leaders move the conversation away from purely technical concerns and toward the questions that matter most to the organization: how to protect people, preserve trust, sustain critical services and recover with confidence. That is especially important as AI makes cyber threats faster, more convincing and harder to anticipate.
3) Understand How To Address That Risk
Understanding resilience is one thing; knowing how to address the risk in practical terms is another. In an AI-enabled threat environment, that means preparing for risks that can evolve quickly and appear credible at scale. But communication should also lead to action: clearer priorities, better preparation and shared confidence in how the organization will respond when disruption occurs.
To lead successfully on cybersecurity, today’s nonprofit leaders must be able to simplify and communicate the complexity of cyber risk to the business. Speaking the language of resilience often means asking the right questions, such as:
- Immediate impact: Which systems are down, and what manual processes are available to keep critical services running?
- Business continuity: How long can the organization operate safely in degraded mode and what are the key actions within this timescale?
- Data exposure: What do we know (and/or not yet know) about whether sensitive information was accessed?
- Decision points: Do we focus on: restoring backups, isolating additional systems, notifying regulators or bringing in external response support?
- Compliance, legal and regulatory issues: What are the potential liability and compliance issues? Is engagement with law enforcement required?
A nonprofit leader who leads on cybersecurity must be able to translate a highly technical incident into the organizational questions the Board inevitably will have: Can we keep operating? What is the risk to members and/or donors? What decisions are needed now? What trade-offs are we making?
Addressing the risk does not mean every nonprofit needs the same level of cybersecurity investment or technical sophistication. It means leaders should understand their organization’s risk tolerance, prioritize the systems and data that are most critical to mission delivery and make sure response plans, decision-making roles and external support are in place before an incident occurs.
Being able to answer these questions, and more, is the difference between checking the cybersecurity boxes and leading on cybersecurity to achieve organizational resilience.
4) Lead Through Uncertainty.
As noted by TechSoup, three out of four nonprofits (76%) lack a formal AI strategy. Yet organizations of all sizes already are adopting AI. Recent ISC2 research on AI and the cybersecurity profession found that the effective use of AI depends heavily on clear practices and strong governance. About 4 in 5 participants said that it’s very important to determine when to trust AI outputs (82%), when to override or ignore AI recommendations (80%) and to have clear expectations, policies and governance frameworks around AI use (80%).
For nonprofit organizations, that pace of change can feel overwhelming. Many may rely on a managed service provider or other partner to help protect their systems and operations. But in this new AI-enabled environment, one thing is clear: while leaders can outsource technical support, you cannot outsource leadership itself.
An integral part of this type of leadership in the AI age is leading through uncertainty and preparing your organization for what may come next.
The people aspect of the standard triad of any cybersecurity strategy (people, process, and technology) will be the one constant that will help your organization maintain resilience as the guiding north star. So, the real question is how your organization chooses to navigate transformation and lead through change: with curiosity, with clarity and with the confidence to keep learning even as the ground shifts beneath.
5) Celebrate Human Skills
It is important to ensure you don’t get swept away in the frenzy of AI and focus instead on where AI investments need to be coupled with human governance and oversight. ISC2 research on AI in cybersecurity indicated that AI is not replacing cybersecurity professionals; instead, it is changing what the profession requires of them. It also revealed something quite interesting, even a bit of a paradox at play: human skills such as critical thinking, decision-making and judgment are becoming more important than ever in the age of AI.
Why? Because human insight and decision-making remain paramount as organizations integrate AI into either their own security operations or those of outsourced managed security providers. Specifically, the AI research found that 65% of survey participants reported spending more time than last year deciding when to trust or act on AI-generated recommendations. Another 63% indicated that they were spending more time reviewing or validating AI outputs.
This data tells leaders that, instead of diminishing the need for people, AI is placing even more emphasis on human judgment and oversight, whether using AI for security or for other functions across the organization.
Leading on Cybersecurity
You do not need to understand every technical threat to understand what is at stake. Your donors have trusted you with their resources. Your staff have committed themselves to your purpose. And the people you serve are counting on you to be there when they need you. Protecting that trust is part of protecting your mission.
And you do not have to do it alone. Ask for help from qualified cybersecurity professionals and seek out resources from organizations such as ISC2’s Center for Cyber Safety and Education. Make sure your team knows who to call, who makes decisions and how essential services will continue if something goes wrong.
AI will keep changing. New threats will emerge. Your responsibility is to make preparedness a priority before a crisis forces it onto the agenda. Just as you prepare for financial, legal or programmatic risks, you must make sure you are leading on cyber risks as well. That is how you advance your mission, even during uncertain times.
*****
Scott Beale, CC, is chief executive officer of cybersecurity nonprofit ISC2 https://www.isc2.org






