Limited Capacity-Building Funding Choking NPOs

(image from pexels.com)

By Richard H. Levey

Funders are hesitant about opening their wallets in support of nonprofits increasing their capacity. Only around 45% make gifts designated for these needs. Instead, potential contributors are more often moved by – and in some cases flat-out earmark donations for – a nonprofit’s mission-related activities.

The impulse is understandable, but it overlooks a harsh reality: For an organization to deliver on its mission, it has to invest in its employees, build out support systems and keep the electricity flowing. Despite this, 69% of leaders at nonprofits indicated the funds available for increasing capacity were “limited,” with another 65% saying constraints on employee time or staff capacity were inhibiting their ability to increase capacity, according to Closing the Capacity Gap, a report from community institution supporter Catalyst Exchange.

Furthermore, just more than half (51%) cited grant funding with restrictions on how it could be used as a capacity-limiting factor. Partly because of these pressures, the median percentage allocated by nonprofits for capacity building is around 1% or 2%.

The tension between supporting an organization’s mission and generating unencumbered funds that meet its basic operational needs is longstanding, but the current climate has brought this conflict into the forefront. Social services, and the materials that support them, are increasingly in demand. At the same time, costs for labor, rent, utilities and other essentials are rising. 

On top of all this, changes in communication channels and new software — AI-influenced and otherwise — are coming online, requiring additional training for nonprofit staffers.

“[Nonprofit staffers often] have not had the training, or call it capacity building, they need to be able to fully leverage these tools to achieve the impacts that they’d like to have,” said Jim Shelton, CEO at Blue Meridian Partners, which sponsored the research undergirding the report. “AI has already created the sense of a disruptive external environment that requires using new tools and resources to adapt to drops in funding and increases in need. It also has presented itself as an opportunity to transform the work inside. But without getting the training on how to do that, or the support to do it well by folks who actually have deep expertise, folks are finding they’re falling short on the promise.”

Faced with this lack of training, nonprofit staffers often use workarounds, such as static spreadsheets, manual reconciliations and other laborious processes. These processes tend to multiply as the organization grows, and integrating them becomes increasingly cumbersome.

 “Eventually, the system itself constrains the organization,” the report authors wrote. “Fixing it now means migrating data, redesigning processes, and retraining staff — all while continuing to operate.” The longer a nonprofit relies on workarounds as opposed to transforming processes, the deeper it goes into what the authors call “capacity debt;” the amount of resources it will take to truly mitigate inefficiency and irreconcilability.

On the plus side, nonprofits where leaders have invested in capacity growth have reaped benefits. According to the report, when there is a good fit between an organization’s need and the support it receives 69% of nonprofit respondents describe the support as “effective,” including 13% who rate it as “highly effective.”

As with many headwinds facing nonprofits, smaller organizations are more likely to feel capacity pressures. Among nonprofits with less than $1 million in annual revenue, “25% regularly struggle to meet funding needs, against 6% of larger organizations; 34% do not know where to start, against 16%, and 27% see no significant improvement, roughly twice the larger-organization rate,” according to the report’s authors.

The report’s authors makes several recommendations for successfully boosting capacity. They include:

* Treating capacity as a core support need for mission and impact, and making that need, along with its costs and benefits, transparent to funders.

* Having clear goals regarding what capacity needs to be strengthened, and freedom from funder influence in steering the process of finding and investing in the correct applications that will result in their capacity goals.

* Building capacity with an eye toward the organization’s trajectory, as opposed to designing systems based on where it is right now.

* Recognizing capacity building is not a one-time exercise. Investment needs to be continuous, and the beneficial outputs and results should be amplified to all stakeholders, including those outside the organization who might be funding subsequent capacity-building efforts.

First, however, nonprofit leaders will need to solve the communication problem.

“We’ve gotten to a place where nonprofits don’t believe [if] they tell the story of their own needs about what it actually takes for them to build the capacity, to deliver well on the promises they’re making, that that will be well received by funders,” Shelton said. So, they feel the need to leave it out.

“What I would love is for narratives to once again be much more open, much more honest about what it really takes to execute on the thing they trying to get done,” Shelton continued. “Here is what it’s going to take for me to be successful at this. Here are my strengths. Here are my gaps. These are the gaps that I can fill with resources. Would you be willing to help me fill those gaps?”

 

The full report is available here: https://catalyst-exchange.org/blog/closing-the-capacity-gap